The Windmill Tavern

Discover The Windmill Tavern Bar & Grill in Windfall, IN—your local spot for delicious breaded tenderloin, steaks, and Taco Tuesday. Enjoy karaoke, pool, darts, trivia, and a relaxing smoking bar atmosphere. Call +1 765-945-4012!

Welcome to The Windmill Tavern

Experience the finest dining

The Windmill Tavern
The Windmill Tavern
The Windmill Tavern
The Windmill Tavern

The Windmill Tavern Bar & Grill, located at 102 N Independence St in Windfall, IN, offers a warm and inviting atmosphere that feels like home. As soon as you walk through the doors, you experience the charm of a small-town bar with a lively spirit. The tavern shines with its delicious menu, where patrons rave about the breaded tenderloin and a variety of savory appetizers. Whether you drop by for a casual lunch, a night of karaoke, or a Saturday evening filled with darts and pool, this establishment provides a unique blend of community and excitement. Friendly staff and welcoming locals turn every visit into a comfortable gathering place to unwind and connect.

The Windmill Tavern boasts an array of features that cater to diverse tastes. Entertainment options include karaoke nights, trivia contests, and well-maintained pool tables, creating a vibrant atmosphere that keeps the energy alive. The menu includes 35 mouth-watering options, from appetizers like breaded mushrooms to hearty sandwiches. Dive into Taco Tuesdays for flavorful treats or savor a delicious steak any other day of the week. The tavern allows smoking, accommodating those who enjoy a smoke while sipping their drink. On peak nights, the bar reaches 100% capacity, especially Friday at 9 PM, making it the perfect place to socialize or join in the fun.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

102 N Independence St, Windfall, IN 46076, United States

Phone

+1 765-945-4012

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

The Windmill Tavern
The Windmill Tavern
The Windmill Tavern
The Windmill Tavern

Nestled in the heart of Windfall, The Windmill Tavern serves as a community staple since its inception. It mixes culinary favorites with a lively social scene, drawing in locals and visitors alike. The breaded tenderloin stands out, a dish that locals claim holds the title of the best in town. Patrons also enjoy a diverse menu featuring appetizers and hearty sandwiches, perfect for a quick bite or a relaxing meal. Forking over an average price of around $14.92 for a meal here balances quality and value, making it a go-to spot for budget-friendly meals without skimping on taste.

Operating hours cater to every schedule, with lunch peak at 11 AM – 2 PM and vibrant dinners from 5 PM – 8 PM, particularly busy on Saturdays.

The tavern runs specials that encourage community engagement, like Taco Tuesday—an enticing way to draw diners in with flavorful dishes at affordable prices. Regular events foster camaraderie, be it a trivia challenge or karaoke showdown, transforming a typical evening into an exciting experience.

The walls of The Windmill Tavern are adorned with memorabilia that reflects Windfall’s history and charm. It resonates with visitors who appreciate local roots. The relaxed ambiance complements the friendly staff, who know many customers by name, adding to the allure that makes regulars feel at home. Dining here is more than just eating; it's about connecting with your community.

The Windmill Tavern

The exterior of The Windmill Tavern features a charming, rustic facade that invites visitors to explore what's inside. Bright signage and welcoming entrances create an inviting vibe, harmonizing with the small-town atmosphere of Windfall. Outdoor seating allows guests to enjoy their meals in the fresh air, especially during warm months, letting laughter and the clink of glasses fill the space. The overall vibe marries snug comfort with a hint of excitement, making it an appealing stop for anyone passing through or living nearby.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday11 AM-12 AM
  • Wednesday11 AM-12 AM
  • Thursday11 AM-12 AM
  • Friday11 AM-3 AM
  • Saturday11 AM-3 AM

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

My chicken strips and drink of choice (water), were delicious. I had heard the food was good here, so we decided to give them a try. The chicken stripe were moist on the inside and crispy on the outside. The fries were egg dipped and fried to crunchy perfection. Water is water. Lol Then barkeep / waitress, perfect! Friendly, kind, suggestive, and helpful. She check on us several times during the meal making sure of our needs. Well done Windmill Tavern! Well DONE!

P
Pendleton

CJ is an amazing bartender! Great food and drinks! Wednesday trivia is always fun, Tuesday for taco Tuesday, karaoke Friday & Saturday great small town bar!

N
Nichole A.

Food was good. Service? Well lets just say she spent more time chit chatting with people than paying attention to our table. We did feel a little neglected when trying to get our check. But we will be back. I do wish they didn't allow smoking inside until after 9pm.

A
Anthony M.

Kate and Kendra killed it! The kitchen staff was on point, with quick and delicious food! Jason with Indy.BrainBrew always delivers a fun and awesome time with trivia!

D
David L.

amazing experience amazing people amazing staff amazing food amazing karaoke just all around amazing everything so if y'all ever in windfall Indiana stop in and check them out karaoke bands or just eating and drinking black and blue highly recommend this place.

b
blacc s.

Great food, fantastic people! Trivia always fun

D
Debbie F.